Bitcoin Treasury: Questions CFOs Ask
STRAIGHT ANSWERS FOR DECISION-MAKERS
The questions we hear most from CFOs, boards, and finance teams evaluating Bitcoin treasury strategy.
How is Bitcoin treated for accounting purposes in Canada?
Under IFRS (and similarly under ASPE), Bitcoin is typically classified as an intangible asset with an indefinite useful life. It's measured at cost less impairment — meaning you write down losses but don't write up gains until you sell. Some companies elect fair value through profit or loss under IAS 38, which allows mark-to-market treatment. We help you evaluate which approach fits your financial reporting objectives and work with your auditors to implement it.
What about volatility? How do we manage that risk?
Volatility is real and requires proper framing. First: position sizing. Most companies allocate 1-10% of treasury to Bitcoin — meaningful enough to matter if the thesis plays out, small enough to not impair operations if it doesn't. Second: time horizon. Bitcoin is a long-term treasury asset, not a trading position. Companies with 3-5+ year horizons have historically been rewarded. Third: the alternative. Cash isn't "safe" — it loses 5-7% of purchasing power annually to monetary expansion. The question isn't whether Bitcoin is volatile; it's whether that volatility is acceptable given the alternative of guaranteed purchasing power erosion.
How do we custody Bitcoin securely?
Institutional custody has matured significantly. Canadian companies typically use qualified custodians — regulated entities that hold Bitcoin in segregated cold storage with institutional-grade security, insurance, and SOC 2 compliance. We evaluate custodians based on your requirements: segregated vs. omnibus accounts, insurance coverage, geographic jurisdiction, withdrawal controls, and integration with your existing finance workflows. For larger positions, multi-signature arrangements add another layer of control.
What are the tax implications?
CRA treats Bitcoin as a commodity for tax purposes. When you sell, you realize a capital gain or loss — 50% of which is taxable (for gains) or deductible (for losses). Holding Bitcoin doesn't trigger tax; only disposition does. For companies accepting Bitcoin as payment, the fair market value at time of receipt is treated as revenue. We structure acquisitions and holding strategies to optimize tax treatment within CRA guidelines, and coordinate with your tax advisors on implementation.
Is this legal? What about regulations?
Yes, holding Bitcoin as a corporate treasury asset is legal in Canada. There's no prohibition on Canadian companies owning Bitcoin. The regulatory framework primarily applies to businesses that deal in Bitcoin (exchanges, dealers) rather than companies that hold it as a treasury asset. That said, proper compliance structure matters: working with FINTRAC-registered vendors, maintaining appropriate documentation, and ensuring your board has approved the treasury policy. We help you build a compliance-ready framework that satisfies auditors and regulators.
How do we explain this to our board?
Board education is often the critical path. We provide executive education sessions tailored to board-level audiences — focused on monetary economics, the corporate treasury case, risk frameworks, and peer company analysis. We also prepare board presentation materials: the strategic rationale, proposed policy, risk assessment, and recommended position size. The goal is to give your board the context they need to make an informed decision, not to "sell" them on Bitcoin.
What if Bitcoin fails?
Bitcoin is a decentralized protocol that has operated continuously since 2009 with near-perfect uptime. It has survived every attempt to break, ban, or discredit it. If governments could have stopped it, they would have. The network is now secured by more computational power than any system in history, and institutional adoption is accelerating. That said, position sizing still matters — we help you allocate appropriately for your risk tolerance so the thesis can play out over time.
Who else is doing this?
Over 70 public companies now hold Bitcoin on their balance sheets, including Strategy (formerly MicroStrategy), Tesla, Block, and Metaplanet. In Canada, adoption is earlier but growing. The more relevant question is: what's your competitive position if your industry peers adopt Bitcoin treasury strategy and you don't? We help you evaluate the strategic implications for your specific sector and competitive landscape.
Why not just buy a Bitcoin ETF?
ETFs are simpler but come with trade-offs. You pay management fees (0.25-1%+ annually), you don't actually own Bitcoin (you own shares of a trust), and you can't use Bitcoin as collateral or for payments. For smaller allocations or companies that need brokerage account simplicity, ETFs can make sense. For larger positions or companies that want full control and optionality, direct ownership is usually preferable. We help you evaluate which approach fits your situation.
How long does implementation take?
From initial engagement to first Bitcoin acquisition: typically 8-10 weeks. That includes executive education, treasury assessment, board presentation, policy development, vendor selection, and execution. The timeline can compress or extend depending on your board meeting schedule and internal approval processes. We've designed the engagement to move as fast as your organization can absorb it.
MORE QUESTIONS?
Book a 30-minute call. We'll answer whatever's on your mind.
BOOK YOUR STRATEGY SESSION© 2026 New Macro Treasury Consulting Inc.